A Rectangular Patio with a Known Area and a Length 3 m More Than Its Width
A rectangular patio is 3 m longer than it is wide, and its area is 40 m2. (a) Find the width and the length of the patio. (b) An edging strip runs all the way round the patio. How long is the strip?
The area of a rectangle is its length multiplied by its width. With the width as the unknown, the area gives an equation in which the unknown is multiplied by itself, which is a quadratic equation. It is solved by bringing every term to one side and factorizing.
- Let the width be x m. The length is 3 m more, so it is (x + 3) m. The area is length times width, so x(x + 3) = 40.
- Expand the bracket: x2 + 3x = 40. Subtract 40 from both sides, so that one side is zero: x2 + 3x − 40 = 0.
- Factorize. Two numbers with a product of −40 and a sum of 3 are 8 and −5, so (x + 8)(x − 5) = 0.
- A product is zero only when one of its factors is zero, so x = −8 or x = 5. A width cannot be negative, so x = −8 is rejected. (a) The width is 5 m and the length is 5 + 3 = 8 m. Check: 5 × 8 = 40.
- (b) The strip is the perimeter of the patio: 2 × (5 + 8) = 26 m.
answer(a) The width is 5 m and the length is 8 m; (b) 26 m
techniqueForming Quadratic Equations · Solving by Factoring
examsO-Level · SAT · GCSE Higher
Common pitfalls
- Solving x(x + 3) = 40 by writing x = 40 or x + 3 = 40. Only a product of zero forces one of its factors to be zero, so the equation must be rearranged to x2 + 3x − 40 = 0 before it is factorized.
- Giving both x = −8 and x = 5 as widths. Both numbers satisfy the equation, but x is a length in meters, and a length cannot be negative.
A Right-Angled Shade Sail with Edges x and x + 7 and a Known Longest Edge
A shade sail is a right-angled triangle. The two edges that meet at the right angle are x m and (x + 7) m long, and the longest edge is 13 m long. (a) Find x and the lengths of the two shorter edges. (b) Find the area of the sail.
Pythagoras' theorem says that in a right-angled triangle the square of the longest side, the hypotenuse, is equal to the sum of the squares of the other two sides. Here both shorter sides are written in terms of x, so the theorem gives a quadratic equation in x.
- By Pythagoras' theorem, the squares of the two shorter edges add up to the square of the hypotenuse: x2 + (x + 7)2 = 132.
- Expand: (x + 7)2 = x2 + 14x + 49 and 132 = 169, so 2x2 + 14x + 49 = 169.
- Subtract 169 from both sides: 2x2 + 14x − 120 = 0. Divide both sides by 2: x2 + 7x − 60 = 0.
- Factorize. Two numbers with a product of −60 and a sum of 7 are 12 and −5, so (x + 12)(x − 5) = 0, which gives x = −12 or x = 5. A length cannot be negative, so x = −12 is rejected. (a) x = 5, and the edges are 5 m and 5 + 7 = 12 m long. Check: 52 + 122 = 25 + 144 = 169 = 132.
- (b) The two shorter edges meet at the right angle, so one is the base and the other is the height: the area is 12 × 5 × 12 = 30 m2.
answer(a) x = 5, so the edges are 5 m and 12 m long; (b) 30 m2
techniqueForming Quadratic Equations · Solving by Factoring
examsO-Level · SAT · GCSE Higher
Common pitfalls
- Expanding (x + 7)2 as x2 + 49. The bracket is multiplied by itself, (x + 7)(x + 7), and that gives the middle term 14x as well.
- Writing x + (x + 7) = 13. Pythagoras' theorem relates the squares of the sides, not the sides themselves, and in any triangle the two shorter sides add up to more than the longest side.
A Ball Thrown Straight Up: When It Lands and How High It Goes
A ball is thrown straight up from the ground. After m seconds its height is h meters, where h = 20m − 5m2. (a) After how many seconds does the ball land? (b) What is the greatest height that the ball reaches, and when does it reach it?
The ball is on the ground whenever its height is zero, so the landing time is a root of 20m − 5m2 = 0. The greatest height is read from the completed-square form of the formula: a square is never negative, so the height is largest when the squared bracket is zero.
- The ball is on the ground when h = 0, so 20m − 5m2 = 0. Both terms have the factor 5m: 5m(4 − m) = 0.
- One of the factors is zero, so m = 0 or m = 4. The root m = 0 is the moment the ball is thrown. (a) The ball lands after 4 seconds. Check: 20 × 4 − 5 × 42 = 80 − 80 = 0.
- Take out the factor −5: h = −5(m2 − 4m). Half of 4 is 2, and (m − 2)2 = m2 − 4m + 4, so m2 − 4m = (m − 2)2 − 4.
- Substitute this into the bracket: h = −5[(m − 2)2 − 4] = 20 − 5(m − 2)2.
- The square (m − 2)2 is never negative, so h is never more than 20, and h = 20 when m = 2. (b) The greatest height is 20 meters, reached 2 seconds after the ball is thrown. Check: at m = 1 and at m = 3 the height is 15 meters, which is lower.
answer(a) After 4 seconds; (b) 20 meters, reached 2 seconds after the ball is thrown
techniqueCompleting the Square · Solving by Factoring · Sketching from Vertex and Factored Form
examsO-Level · SAT · GCSE Higher
Common pitfalls
- Dividing both sides of 20m − 5m2 = 0 by m and keeping only m = 4 without a reason. Dividing by m loses the root m = 0. It is better to factorize, find both roots, and then say that m = 0 is the moment of the throw.
- Giving the landing time, 4 seconds, as the time of the greatest height. The ball is highest halfway through its flight, at m = 2, which is the value that makes the squared bracket zero.
A Frame of Constant Width Round a Picture with the Framed Area Known
A picture is 30 cm long and 20 cm wide. A frame of the same width all the way round is fitted to it, and the picture and the frame together cover 900 cm2. (a) Find the width of the frame, correct to 2 decimal places. (b) A thin gold line is painted along the outer edge of the frame. How long is the line, to the nearest centimeter?
The frame adds its width to both ends of each side, so each outer side is the side of the picture plus twice the width. The area of the outer rectangle gives a quadratic equation. Its roots are not whole numbers, so it is solved by the quadratic formula: the roots of ax2 + bx + c = 0 are x = −b ± √b2 − 4ac2a.
- Let the width of the frame be x cm. The frame adds x cm at both ends of each side, so the outer rectangle is (30 + 2x) cm by (20 + 2x) cm, and (20 + 2x)(30 + 2x) = 900.
- Expand: 600 + 40x + 60x + 4x2 = 900, which is 4x2 + 100x + 600 = 900. Subtract 900 from both sides: 4x2 + 100x − 300 = 0. Divide both sides by 4: x2 + 25x − 75 = 0.
- No two whole numbers have a product of −75 and a sum of 25, so use the quadratic formula x = −b ± √b2 − 4ac2a with a = 1, b = 25 and c = −75. First, b2 − 4ac = 625 + 300 = 925.
- So x = −25 ± √9252, and √925 ≈ 30.414. This gives x ≈ 2.707 or x ≈ −27.707. A width cannot be negative, so the second root is rejected. (a) The frame is 2.71 cm wide, correct to 2 decimal places.
- (b) Keep the unrounded width. The outer sides are 30 + 2 × 2.707 = 35.414 cm and 20 + 2 × 2.707 = 25.414 cm, so the line is 2 × (35.414 + 25.414) = 121.656 cm long, which is 122 cm to the nearest centimeter.
answer(a) 2.71 cm; (b) 122 cm
techniqueThe Quadratic Formula · Forming Quadratic Equations
examsO-Level · SAT · GCSE Higher
Common pitfalls
- Writing the outer sides as 30 + x and 20 + x. The frame runs along both ends of each side, so each side grows by 2x.
- Setting the area of the frame alone equal to 900 cm2. The 900 cm2 is covered by the picture and the frame together, so it is the area of the whole outer rectangle.
Two Sisters' Ages with a Known Sum and a Known Product
The ages of two sisters add up to 19 years, and the product of their ages is 84. (a) Write down a quadratic equation whose roots are the two ages, and solve it. (b) How many years ago was the older sister exactly twice as old as the younger sister?
A quadratic equation with roots α and β is (x − α)(x − β) = 0, which expands to x2 − (α + β)x + αβ = 0. So when the sum and the product of two numbers are known, the equation that has them as roots can be written down at once: x2 − (sum)x + (product) = 0.
- Let the two ages be the roots of a quadratic equation. The sum of the roots is 19 and their product is 84, so the equation is x2 − 19x + 84 = 0.
- Factorize. The product 84 is positive and the sum is −19, so both numbers are negative: they are −7 and −12, and (x − 7)(x − 12) = 0.
- So x = 7 or x = 12, and both roots are used, one for each sister. (a) The equation is x2 − 19x + 84 = 0, and the sisters are 7 and 12 years old. Check: 7 + 12 = 19 and 7 × 12 = 84.
- Let it be k years ago. Then the sisters were (12 − k) and (7 − k) years old, so 12 − k = 2(7 − k). Expand the bracket: 12 − k = 14 − 2k. Add 2k to both sides: 12 + k = 14. Subtract 12 from both sides: k = 2.
- (b) It was 2 years ago, when the sisters were 10 and 5 years old. Check: 10 = 2 × 5.
answer(a) x2 − 19x + 84 = 0; the sisters are 7 and 12 years old; (b) 2 years ago
techniqueThe Sum and Product of the Roots · Solving by Factoring
examsSAT
Common pitfalls
- Writing the equation as x2 + 19x + 84 = 0. The coefficient of x is the sum of the roots with its sign changed, because (x − 7)(x − 12) expands to x2 − 19x + 84. The equation with +19x has the roots −7 and −12.
- Rejecting one of the two roots out of habit. A root is rejected only when the situation rules it out, and here the two roots are the two ages that the question asks for.
The Range of Prices for Which a Stall Makes a Profit
A drinks stall sells a cup of juice for x dollars. Its profit for a day is P dollars, where P = −5x2 + 60x − 100. (a) For which prices does the stall make a profit? (b) Which price gives the greatest profit, and how much is that profit?
The stall makes a profit when P is more than zero, which is a quadratic inequality. Its roots are the prices at which the profit is exactly zero, and the graph of P shows on which side of the roots the profit is positive. The graph is symmetrical, so its highest point is halfway between the roots.
- The stall makes a profit when P > 0, so −5x2 + 60x − 100 > 0. Divide both sides by −5. Dividing by a negative number reverses the inequality sign: x2 − 12x + 20 < 0.
- Factorize: two numbers with a product of 20 and a sum of −12 are −2 and −10, so (x − 2)(x − 10) < 0. The profit is exactly zero at the roots x = 2 and x = 10.
- The coefficient of x2 in P is negative, so the graph of P opens downward, and it is above the x-axis between the roots. Test a price in each part: at x = 6, P = −180 + 360 − 100 = 80, and at x = 1 and at x = 11, P = −45.
- (a) The stall makes a profit when 2 < x < 10, that is, when a cup costs more than $2 and less than $10.
- (b) The highest point of the graph is halfway between the roots, at x = 2 + 102 = 6, where P = 80. The greatest profit is $80 a day, at a price of $6 a cup.
answer(a) 2 < x < 10: a price of more than $2 and less than $10; (b) a price of $6, which gives a profit of $80
techniqueSolving a Quadratic Inequality · Sketching from Vertex and Factored Form
examsO-Level · GCSE Higher · H2
Common pitfalls
- Dividing by −5 and keeping the sign as >. Dividing both sides of an inequality by a negative number reverses the sign, so x2 − 12x + 20 must be less than zero.
- Answering x < 2 or x > 10. That is where x2 − 12x + 20 is positive, which is where the profit is negative. A test price such as x = 6, where P = 80, shows which part of the number line is wanted.
Whether a Given Length of Fencing Can Enclose a Given Area
A farmer has 40 m of fencing to make a rectangular pen, and he uses all of it. (a) Can the pen have an area of 120 m2? (b) What is the greatest area that the pen can have, and what shape is it then?
The width of a pen with a given area is a root of a quadratic equation. For ax2 + bx + c = 0 the number b2 − 4ac is called the discriminant. When it is positive the equation has two real roots, when it is zero it has one, and when it is negative it has none. If there is no real root, there is no width that works, so the pen cannot be made.
- The perimeter is 40 m, so the length and the width add up to 20 m. Let the width be x m. Then the length is (20 − x) m, and an area of 120 m2 needs x(20 − x) = 120.
- Expand the bracket: 20x − x2 = 120. Add x2 to both sides and subtract 20x from both sides: x2 − 20x + 120 = 0.
- Here a = 1, b = −20 and c = 120, so the discriminant is b2 − 4ac = (−20)2 − 4 × 1 × 120 = 400 − 480 = −80. It is negative, so the equation has no real roots. (a) No width gives 120 m2, so the pen cannot have that area.
- The area of the pen is A = 20x − x2 = −(x2 − 20x). Half of 20 is 10, and (x − 10)2 = x2 − 20x + 100, so x2 − 20x = (x − 10)2 − 100 and A = 100 − (x − 10)2.
- The square (x − 10)2 is never negative, so A is never more than 100, and A = 100 when x = 10. (b) The greatest area is 100 m2, when the pen is a square of side 10 m. Check: a pen of 9 m by 11 m has an area of 99 m2.
answer(a) No: the discriminant is −80, so no width gives an area of 120 m2; (b) 100 m2, when the pen is a square of side 10 m
techniqueThe Discriminant and the Nature of the Roots · Completing the Square · Forming Quadratic Equations
examsO-Level · SAT · GCSE Higher
Common pitfalls
- Letting the length be (40 − x) m. The 40 m is the whole perimeter, which is two lengths and two widths, so one length and one width add up to 20 m.
- Working out b2 as −400 because b = −20. The square of a negative number is positive: (−20)2 = 400, and the discriminant is 400 − 480 = −80.
Where a Straight Beam Crosses a Parabolic Arch
The arch of a bridge follows the curve y = 6x − x2, where x m is the distance along the ground from the left foot of the arch and y m is the height. A straight steel beam follows the line y = x + 4. (a) Find the coordinates of the two points where the beam meets the arch. (b) Find the length of the beam between these two points, correct to 2 decimal places.
At a point where the beam meets the arch, the same x and y satisfy both equations. Substituting the expression for y from the line into the curve leaves a quadratic equation in x alone. Each root is the x-coordinate of one meeting point, and the line then gives its y-coordinate.
- At a meeting point both equations hold, so the two expressions for y are equal: x + 4 = 6x − x2.
- Add x2 to both sides and subtract 6x from both sides: x2 − 5x + 4 = 0. Its discriminant is b2 − 4ac = 25 − 16 = 9, which is positive, so there are two real roots and the beam meets the arch at two points.
- Factorize: two numbers with a product of 4 and a sum of −5 are −1 and −4, so (x − 1)(x − 4) = 0, and x = 1 or x = 4.
- Substitute each root into y = x + 4: y = 5 when x = 1, and y = 8 when x = 4. (a) The beam meets the arch at (1, 5) and (4, 8). Check in the curve: 6 × 1 − 12 = 5 and 6 × 4 − 42 = 8.
- (b) From (1, 5) to (4, 8) the beam goes 3 m across and 3 m up. These are the two shorter sides of a right-angled triangle, so by Pythagoras' theorem the length is √32 + 32 = √18 ≈ 4.24 m.
answer(a) (1, 5) and (4, 8); (b) √18 ≈ 4.24 m
techniqueA Linear Equation Paired with a Quadratic · When a Line Meets, Touches or Misses a Curve
examsO-Level · SAT · GCSE Higher
Common pitfalls
- Stopping at x = 1 and x = 4. A point has two coordinates, so each root must be substituted back to find its y-coordinate. The linear equation is the easier one to use.
- Adding the two equations as if they were a pair of linear equations. Elimination by adding or subtracting cannot remove x2 here. Substitution works because both equations give y in terms of x.
A Journey Shortened by an Hour When the Speed Rises by 10 km/h
A lorry makes a journey of 300 km. If its average speed were 10 km/h faster than usual, the journey would take 1 hour less. (a) Find the usual average speed of the lorry. (b) How long would the journey take at the faster speed?
Time is distance divided by speed. With the usual speed as the unknown, each of the two times is a fraction with the unknown in its denominator, and their difference is 1 hour. Multiplying both sides by both denominators clears the fractions and leaves a quadratic equation.
- Let the usual speed be v km/h. Time is distance divided by speed, so the usual time is 300v hours and the faster time is 300v + 10 hours. The faster journey is 1 hour shorter: 300v − 300v + 10 = 1.
- Multiply both sides by v(v + 10) to clear the fractions: 300(v + 10) − 300v = v(v + 10).
- Expand: 300v + 3000 − 300v = v2 + 10v, so 3000 = v2 + 10v. Subtract 3000 from both sides: v2 + 10v − 3000 = 0.
- Factorize: two numbers with a product of −3000 and a sum of 10 are 60 and −50, so (v + 60)(v − 50) = 0, and v = −60 or v = 50. A speed cannot be negative, so v = −60 is rejected. (a) The usual speed is 50 km/h.
- (b) The faster speed is 50 + 10 = 60 km/h, so the journey would take 30060 = 5 hours. Check: the usual time is 30050 = 6 hours, and 6 − 5 = 1 hour.
answer(a) 50 km/h; (b) 5 hours
techniqueFractional Equations · Solving by Factoring
examsO-Level · SAT · GCSE Higher
Common pitfalls
- Writing 300v + 10 − 300v = 1. The faster journey takes less time, so the usual time is the larger fraction, and the smaller one is subtracted from it.
- Multiplying only the two fractions by v(v + 10) and leaving the right-hand side as 1. Every term on both sides is multiplied, so the right-hand side becomes v(v + 10).
A Cost of Making Each Mug That Can Never Be Zero
A workshop makes mugs. In a week when it makes x hundred mugs, the cost of making each mug is C dollars, where C = x2 − 12x + 50. (a) Show that the cost of making a mug can never be zero. (b) Find the least cost of making a mug, and the number of mugs made in a week that gives it.
Completing the square writes the expression as a squared bracket plus a number. A squared bracket is never negative, so the whole expression is never less than that number. If the number is positive, the expression is always positive, and the number is its least value.
- Half of 12 is 6, and (x − 6)2 = x2 − 12x + 36, so x2 − 12x = (x − 6)2 − 36.
- Substitute this into the formula: C = (x − 6)2 − 36 + 50 = (x − 6)2 + 14.
- The square (x − 6)2 is never negative, so C is at least 14 for every value of x. (a) The cost is always positive, so it can never be zero. The discriminant agrees: b2 − 4ac = 144 − 200 = −56 is negative, so x2 − 12x + 50 = 0 has no real roots.
- (b) C is least when (x − 6)2 = 0, which is when x = 6. The least cost is $14 for each mug, when 600 mugs are made in a week. Check: at x = 5 and at x = 7 the cost is 1 + 14 = $15.
answer(a) C = (x − 6)2 + 14, which is at least 14, so it is never zero; (b) $14, when 600 mugs are made in a week
techniqueAlways Positive or Always Negative Quadratics · Completing the Square · The Discriminant and the Nature of the Roots
Common pitfalls
- Substituting a few values of x, finding that each cost is positive, and stopping there. A few values show nothing about all the others. The completed square (x − 6)2 + 14 is at least 14 for every x.
- Giving the least cost as $6. The 6 in the bracket is the value of x at which the cost is least, which means 600 mugs. The least cost is the number added outside the bracket, $14.
Equal Margins Around a Poster with Half the Sheet Printed, and a Formula for Any Sheet
A designer lays out a poster on a sheet 60 cm long and 40 cm wide. The printing fills a rectangle in the middle, with a blank margin of the same width, x cm, all the way around it, and the printing must cover exactly half of the sheet. (a) Complete the square to find the width of the margin, correct to 2 decimal places. (b) The designer wants one formula for every job. For a sheet L cm long and W cm wide with a printed area of A cm2, complete the square to find x in terms of L, W and A, and say which of the two roots is the margin.
Completing the square turns x2 + bx into a squared bracket minus a number, and a square root then undoes the square. It works when the equation does not factorize with whole numbers, and it works just as well with letters in place of the numbers. Made with letters, the same moves give one formula for every sheet: this is how the quadratic formula itself is found from ax2 + bx + c = 0.
- Let the margin be x cm. It runs along both ends of each side, so the printed rectangle is (60 − 2x) cm by (40 − 2x) cm. The sheet covers 60 × 40 = 2400 cm2, and half of it is 1200 cm2, so (60 − 2x)(40 − 2x) = 1200.
- Expand: 2400 − 120x − 80x + 4x2 = 1200, which is 4x2 − 200x + 2400 = 1200. Subtract 1200 from both sides and divide both sides by 4: x2 − 50x + 300 = 0. Then move the constant across: x2 − 50x = −300.
- Complete the square. Half of 50 is 25, and (x − 25)2 = x2 − 50x + 625, so add 625 to both sides: (x − 25)2 = 325. Take the square root of both sides, with both signs: x − 25 = ±√325, so x = 25 ± √325, and √325 ≈ 18.028.
- This gives x ≈ 6.972 or x ≈ 43.028. Two margins of 43.028 cm cannot fit across a sheet only 40 cm wide, so that root is rejected. (a) The margin is 6.97 cm wide, correct to 2 decimal places. Check: 60 − 2x = 10 + 2√325 and 40 − 2x = 2√325 − 10, and their product is 4 × 325 − 100 = 1200.
- (b) Make the same moves with letters. (L − 2x)(W − 2x) = A expands to 4x2 − 2(L + W)x + LW − A = 0. Divide both sides by 4 and move the constant across: x2 − L + W2x = A − LW4. Half of L + W2 is L + W4, so add its square, (L + W)216, to both sides: (x − L + W4)2 = (L + W)2 − 4LW + 4A16 = (L − W)2 + 4A16.
- Take the square root of both sides: x = L + W ± √(L − W)2 + 4A4. Because 4A is positive, the square root is more than W − L, so the root with + is more than L + W + W − L4 = W2, and two margins that wide are wider than the sheet. (b) The margin is x = L + W − √(L − W)2 + 4A4, the root with the minus sign. Check: with L = 60, W = 40 and A = 1200 it gives 100 − √52004 ≈ 6.97 cm, as in (a).
answer(a) 6.97 cm; (b) x = L + W − √(L − W)2 + 4A4, the root with the minus sign
techniqueDeriving the Quadratic Formula · Completing the Square · Forming Quadratic Equations
examsSAT · GCSE Higher
Common pitfalls
- Writing the printed rectangle as (60 − x) cm by (40 − x) cm. The margin runs along both ends of each side, so each side of the printing is 2x shorter than the sheet.
- Adding 25, or adding 625 to the left-hand side only. Completing the square adds the square of half the coefficient of x, which is 252 = 625, and whatever is added to one side must be added to the other.
The Braking Distance of a Car from Its Whole Stopping Distance, and Whether It Was Speeding
On a dry road, a car braking hard slows down by 8 m/s2, so a car that stops over a braking distance of d m was traveling at v = 4√d m/s when the brakes went on. A driver sees a deer on the road. The car keeps its speed for her reaction time of 1 second, and then she brakes to a stop. From the moment she saw the deer to the moment the car stopped, it traveled 60 m. (a) Find the braking distance. (b) The speed limit on the road is 80 km/h. Was the car over the limit when she saw the deer?
The braking distance sits under a square root in the formula for the speed. Getting the root alone on one side and squaring both sides gives a quadratic equation, but squaring also accepts a value that made the two sides equal in size and opposite in sign. So each root of the quadratic is checked in the equation before squaring, and a root that fails it is rejected.
- Let the braking distance be d m. The car was traveling at 4√d m/s, so in the 1 second before the brakes went on it covered 4√d m. The two distances add up to 60 m: 4√d + d = 60.
- Get the square root alone on one side: 4√d = 60 − d. Square both sides: 16d = 3600 − 120d + d2.
- Bring every term to one side: d2 − 136d + 3600 = 0. Two numbers with a product of 3600 and a sum of −136 are −36 and −100, so (d − 36)(d − 100) = 0, and d = 36 or d = 100.
- Squaring can bring in a root that the equation before squaring does not have, so check each one in 4√d = 60 − d. For d = 36: 4 × 6 = 24 and 60 − 36 = 24, which agree. For d = 100: 4 × 10 = 40, but 60 − 100 = −40. Squaring turned 40 = −40 into 1600 = 1600, so d = 100 is rejected; a braking distance of 100 m cannot fit inside a stop of 60 m in any case. (a) The braking distance was 36 m.
- (b) The speed was v = 4√36 = 24 m/s. An hour has 3600 seconds and a kilometer has 1000 m, so this is 24 × 3.6 = 86.4 km/h. Yes: the car was over the limit of 80 km/h. Check: 24 m during the reaction and 36 m of braking make 60 m.
answer(a) 36 m; (b) yes: the car was traveling at 24 m/s, which is 86.4 km/h
techniqueSolving Equations with a Square Root · Solving by Factoring · Forming Quadratic Equations
Common pitfalls
- Squaring each term of 4√d + d = 60 on its own to get 16d + d2 = 3600. The square of a sum is not the sum of the squares, so get the root alone on one side first and then square each whole side.
- Keeping d = 100 because it satisfies the quadratic. In the equation before squaring it gives 40 = −40, which is false: squaring made a false equation true, so the root is not a solution.
A Tour Boat Against a River Current: the Speeds for a Trip Upstream, and a Round Trip, Under a Time Limit
A tour boat runs 12 km up a river from a town to a lake, and then back. The river flows at 4 km/h along the whole stretch, and the boat's speed in still water is v km/h. (a) For which speeds v does the trip upstream take less than 1 hour? (b) For which speeds v does the round trip, up to the lake and back, take less than 1 hour 15 minutes, not counting the stop at the lake?
The time for the trip upstream is a fraction with the unknown speed in its denominator, and that denominator is negative for a boat slower than the current. Multiplying through by it would keep the inequality for some speeds and reverse it for others, so everything is brought to one side over one denominator and the sign of each factor is tested. The story then says which speeds are possible.
- Let the boat's speed in still water be v km/h. Against the current it moves upstream at (v − 4) km/h, so the trip takes 12v − 4 hours. The boat makes headway only if v − 4 is positive, so v > 4. The trip takes less than 1 hour when 12v − 4 < 1.
- The sign of v − 4 decides whether multiplying by it keeps or reverses the inequality, so do not multiply. Subtract 1 from both sides and write over one denominator: 12 − (v − 4)v − 4 < 0, which is 16 − vv − 4 < 0. The critical values are v = 16, where the top is zero, and v = 4, where the bottom is zero.
- Test the sign of each factor. For v < 4: the top is positive and the bottom negative, so the quotient is negative. For 4 < v < 16: both are positive, so the quotient is positive. For v > 16: the top is negative and the bottom positive, so the quotient is negative. The inequality holds when v < 4 or v > 16.
- Below 4 km/h the boat is carried downstream and never reaches the lake; the formula gives a negative time there, which is less than 1 but means nothing. Those speeds are rejected. (a) The trip upstream takes less than 1 hour when v > 16 km/h. Check: at v = 20 it takes 1216 = 0.75 hour.
- (b) Downstream the boat moves at (v + 4) km/h, and 1 hour 15 minutes is 54 hours, so 12v − 4 + 12v + 4 < 54. Adding the fractions gives 24v(v − 4)(v + 4) < 54. Subtract 54 and write over one denominator: 96v − 5(v2 − 16)4(v − 4)(v + 4) < 0, which is −5v2 + 96v + 804(v − 4)(v + 4) < 0. Multiply both sides by −4, a negative number, and reverse the sign: (5v + 4)(v − 20)(v − 4)(v + 4) > 0.
- For v > 4 the factors 5v + 4, v − 4 and v + 4 are all positive, so the quotient has the sign of v − 20, and it is positive when v > 20. (b) The round trip takes less than 1 hour 15 minutes when v > 20 km/h. Check: at v = 20 it takes 1216 + 1224 = 0.75 + 0.5 = 1.25 hours, exactly 1 hour 15 minutes, and at v = 24 it takes 0.6 + 1228 ≈ 1.03 hours.
answer(a) v > 16 km/h; (b) v > 20 km/h
techniqueSolving a Rational Inequality · Fractional Equations · Solving a Quadratic Inequality
Common pitfalls
- Multiplying both sides of 12v − 4 < 1 by v − 4 as if it were positive. For speeds below 4 km/h it is negative and the inequality reverses; the sign test covers both cases without guessing.
- Giving the answer to (a) as v < 4 or v > 16. Below 4 km/h the formula gives a negative time, which passes the inequality but means the boat never arrives, so those speeds are rejected.