Substituting gives 0 over 0
At x = 0, sin x is 0 and x is 0, so reads . That is an indeterminate form: it decides nothing, and the limit as has to be found another way.
Here there is no factor to cancel. sin x is not x times anything simpler, so the rewriting that worked for has nothing to work on.
The values near 0
With x in radians, is 0.8415 at x = 1, 0.9589 at x = 0.5, 0.99833 at x = 0.1, and 0.999983 at x = 0.01. The values climb toward 1.
The other side gives the same values, because sin(−x) = −sin x, so . The graph is symmetric about the y-axis, and from both sides it closes in on height 1. At x = 0 itself there is no value, so the graph has a hole at (0, 1).
The graph of for x from −6 to 6, in radians. It is 0 where sin x is, at , and rises to a hollow dot at (0, 1): the height the curve approaches, at the one point where it has no value.
Three areas on the unit circle
Take an angle x with , at the center O of a circle of radius 1. Let A = (1, 0), let P = (cos x, sin x) be the point at angle x on the circle, and let T be where the line OP meets the tangent to the circle at A, the vertical line through A. Then T = (1, tan x), because OAT is a right triangle with OA = 1 and angle x at O.
Three regions sit inside one another. The triangle OAP has base OA = 1 and height sin x, so its area is . The sector OAP has area , a formula that holds only with x in radians. The triangle OAT has base 1 and height tan x, so its area is .
The triangle OAP lies inside the sector, and the sector lies inside the triangle OAT. So , and doubling, sin x < x < tan x.
The angle x = 0.8 radians at O. The shaded sector OAP has area . The dashed triangle OAP inside it has area , and the dashed triangle OAT, with T on the tangent line at A, has area .
The squeeze
Divide sin x < x < tan x by sin x, which is positive for : . All three are positive, and taking reciprocals of positive numbers reverses their order: .
For the same holds, because cos(−x) = cos x and takes the same value at −x as at x. So near 0, on both sides, is trapped between cos x below and 1 above.
As , , and the constant 1 stays at 1. Both bounds tend to 1, so by the squeeze theorem as is 1.
From x = −1.5 to 1.5: the gold curve between the dashed curve y = cos x below and the dashed line y = 1 above. At x = 1.5 they are 0.071, 0.665 and 1; toward x = 0 all three meet at height 1.
Why radians
The area of a sector is only when x is in radians, and the whole argument rests on it. In degrees the answer changes. An angle of x degrees is radians, so , which tends to as . At x = 1 it is already 0.017452.
A limit of 1 says that near 0, sin x and x are nearly the same number: at x = 0.1, sin x = 0.09983. In radians the sine curve leaves the origin running alongside the line y = x. The chord from (0, 0) to (h, sin h) has gradient , which tends to 1, so the gradient of the sine curve at the origin is 1. Working out the gradient of sin x at every point rests on this same limit, and in degrees every such result would carry an extra factor of .
Limits built from this one
For as , write it as . As , as well, so and the limit is 3. At x = 0.01 the value is 2.99955.
For , write tan x as : . At x = 0.01 the value is 1.000033.
For , write it as . The first two factors tend to 1, so the limit is . At x = 0.01 the value is 2.4991.
The usual mistakes
Answering 0 because sin 0 = 0. The denominator tends to 0 as well, and decides nothing.
Canceling the x. is not sin, and sin x is not a product with a factor x to cancel.
Working in degrees. Then tends to , not 1, and the approximation fails.
Bounding the ratio by −1 and 1, or by 0 and 1. Those bounds do not share a limit, so they force nothing. The bounds that close together are cos x and 1.
Reading the limit as an equality. is less than 1 for every ; it only approaches 1.
A satellite’s chord and arc
In the application below, the straight-line distance between two points on an orbit, divided by the distance along the orbit, comes down to with u half the angle between them, so its limit is this one.
Worked example: A Satellite Passing Overhead: When a Straight Line May Stand In for the Arc of Its Orbit
Question A satellite moves on a circular orbit of radius 7000 km. Two positions on the orbit are θ radians apart, so the distance along the orbit is the arc 7000θ km and the distance in a straight line is the chord 2 × 7000 sinθ2 km. (a) Find the limit of the chord divided by the arc as θ → 0. (b) For θ = 0.1 find the arc, the chord, and the difference between them.
1.Write the ratio and cancel the radius: 2 × 7000 sinθ27000θ = 2sinθ2θ. The size of the orbit has gone, and only the angle is left.
Along the orbit the distance is the arc 7000θ km; in a straight line it is the chord 2 × 7000 sinθ2 km. 2.Put u = θ2, so that θ = 2u and the ratio is 2sin u2u = sin uu. As θ → 0 the half-angle u → 0 as well.
The ratio is 2sinθ2θ, and with u = θ2 it is exactly sin uu. 3.The standard limit for an angle in radians is limu → 0 sin uu = 1, so the ratio of the chord to the arc tends to 1.
For an angle in radians, limu → 0 sin uu = 1. The ratio has no value at u = 0, which is the open circle. 4.(a) The limit is 1. For a small enough angle the straight line and the arc agree as closely as you please, which is why a short hop across an orbit may be measured either way.
(a) The limit is 1: for a small enough angle the straight line and the arc agree as closely as you please. 5.(b) The arc is 7000 × 0.1 = 700 km. The chord is 14000 sin 0.05 = 14000 × 0.0499792 = 699.71 km.
(b) The arc is 7000 × 0.1 = 700 km and the chord is 14000sin 0.05 = 699.71 km. 6.The difference is 700 − 699.71 = 0.29 km, about 290 m, which is 0.04% of the arc. Check with the ratio itself: sin 0.050.05 = 0.99958, and 700 × 0.99958 = 699.71 km.
(b) The difference is 0.29 km, about 290 m, which is 0.04% of the arc.
Answer: (a) 1; (b) the arc is 700 km, the chord is 699.71 km, and the difference is 0.29 km, about 290 m
Common mistakes
- Working in degrees. With the angle in degrees sin uu tends to π180 rather than to 1, and the arc formula rθ is wrong as well. Both results belong to radians.
- Reading the limit of 1 as an equality, so that the chord is the arc. The ratio tends to 1 but is below 1 for every angle that is not zero: at θ = 0.1 it is 0.99958, and across 700 km that small shortfall is still 290 m.